I couldn’t resist the temptation to get my hands on the first Android 3.0 (Honeycomb) device and wanted to explore the tablet world outside of iOS a bit, so I bought a Motorola Xoom the day it came out. I’ve now spent a couple of days with the device, downloaded apps, explored all the features, and come to the conclusion that the Motorola Xoom and Android 3.0 are a huge disappointment.
Let’s start with the Xoom hardware problems first:
- It is rather heavy
- The battery life is too short (about 5-6 hours rather than the 10 advertised)
- The power-button is in the most ridiculous spot on the back of the device (next to the camera & flash)
- The plastic snap-on cover is bulky and adds weight and thickness to it
Yes, the screen with HD resolution is nice. But that’s about the only thing that is better than the original iPad.
Now let’s talk about the Android 3.0 issues:
- There are only about 16 apps available that are designed for an Android tablet form-factor. Robert Scoble goes into great detail on that issue in this blog post today.
- When you run a few apps (and download some that are more designed for a phone) you inevitably arrive at a state, where the UI starts to feel sluggish – despite the dual-core CPU. The way that background applications can eat processor cycles and make your foreground application feel incredibly slow is a design flaw that I’ve already observed in the Motorola Droid a year ago. And it hasn’t been fixed in Android 3.0.
- In using the device for a couple of hours, I got multiple apps to crash on me.
- The Android app store is still extremely difficult to navigate and you cannot easily tell the good applications apart from the “me too” junk.
- When connected to an Exchange server and trying to archive a piece of e-mail, the list of available folders is shown by flattening the entire folder hierarchy instead of displaying it properly. Therefore, I have to scroll down for 4-5 pages until I find the folder I need.
- The idea to put widgets on the home screen that are more than just an icon is nice. But the implementation is ridiculous. There are plenty of apps that claim to be a widget, but all they are is an icon. Other apps, such as Twitter, have a widget view, but you cannot control the update frequency. With the CNN widget this leads to flickering and nervous screen updates. Then, when you tap on the widget, it takes forever to load the app and display the news.
- Flash player isn’t available yet.
- There is no movie availability other than YouTube. Nothing even remotely similar to the iTunes store where I can simply rent or buy a movie anytime.
I could go on for a long time. It is simply ridiculous how far from the truth the TV commercial for the Motorola Xoom is.
And, of course, now that the iPad 2 has been announced today, the Xoom looks even worse…